CZ:Contributor Lists

This is part of a proposal that is currently pending. Please do not use!

What are contributor lists?

Contributor lists are alphabetical lists of people who have contributed at least a couple of sentences to the article. A list appears only after at least five contributors.

If a name appears on the list, does that mean the person endorses the current version of the article?

No, not necessarily. In fact, a person may claim to be a contributor in spite of the fact that his or her contribution has been completely removed from the article.

Why are there contributor lists at all?

It is a small honor that might motivate some people to contribute.

How do I get added to a list?

You add yourself, once you have contributed "two substantive sentences," or an equivalent amount of content such as an image or notes, to the article. Add your name alphabetically to the list. For example, if my name is Joe Moe, I would add my name as follows:

{{contribs|John Doe|Joe Moe|Jane Roe}}

Do not skip down a space, and do not add [[ or ]] around your username.

What if I start a new article? Can I add a new contributor list?

Yes. Simply write (at the very bottom of the page): {{contribs|Your Username}} (and, of course, replace "Your Username" with your exact username, without [[ or ]].

What is a "substantive sentence"? What categories of data are "equivalent"?

One that is not particularly short or particularly unimportant. If you claim that a sentence is substantive, we probably won't object. One image or other graphic will earn co-contributor credit, as will two citations in notes; five "related articles" links; three "external links"; and similar amounts of content for data types.

Can someone add you to a contributor list?

Yes, if you have met the requirements to be added to the list, and you have not specifically asked them not to do so.

Can I remove myself from the list?

Yes, and no one may prevent you from doing so.

I created a list, or added myself to a list, but I don't see my name. Why not?

Probably because there are fewer than five names on the list.

Why don't you display fewer than five names?

Because a list of relatively few names would tend to put off people who feel uncomfortable joining what might appear to them to be a small "clique" or "club." Moreover, giving people credit only once the list of names reaches five in length will encourage more robust collaboration in the beginning of the authoring of an article, which is a very good thing.

Isn't the list meaningless if one can be added to it for contributing just a couple of sentences to the article?

It isn't meaningless, because it is a list of people who have, after all, worked some on the article; most people cannot make that claim. We grant that it is a small honor--one that, again, will motivate some people to do work on the wiki and take pride in their work, even if very small.

Why not make the honor more meaningful? Why not restrict credit to "major authors," defined somehow?

Because, in short, to do that would be to recognize people as major authors. This would change the robustly collaborative culture of our project. Probably, this would make people less likely to contribute to articles that they aren't honored for writing. Other projects, such as the Encyclopedia of Earth and Scholarpedia, do recognize major authors, but they do not enjoy nearly the sort of robust collaboration that the Citizendium does. It is best that we not play fast and loose with the very engine--collaboration--that runs the wiki process.

What if we have a disagreement about whether a person should be listed?

Anyone who requests not to be listed must be removed. If a person insists on being included, one may not argue about a Citizen's claim of credit. Only the Constabulary may edit author lists in order to remove a contributor claim, and is generally responsible for settling any objections to a particular contributor listing.

Can contributor lists be added to subpages? How?

Yes. Contributor templates work precisely the same way for subpages, that is, each subpage uses its own contributor template.