CZ:Disambiguation: Difference between revisions

From Citizendium
Jump to navigation Jump to search
imported>Meg Taylor
(clarify)
mNo edit summary
 
(46 intermediate revisions by one other user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
A '''disambiguation page''' is a page designed to help readers find the correct page when two or more articles deal with subjects with the same or similar names, whether the subjects differ in meaning or not. To ''disambiguate'' a word or phrase is to clarify which sense of the word or phrase is meant, or to list out all the different possible meanings of the word or phrase, or different expressions of the meaningDisambiguation pages should not be used either to give ''all'' the possible senses used in English, but only ones that designate Citizendium articles; and should list only articles that ''really could'' be confused with the word or phrase in the title of the disambiguation page.  A good example is [[reel]].
{{Content Policy}}
{{Image|Disambiguation in Citizendium.jpg|left|600px|The Snake redirect needs to be restored, as Citizendium handles disambiguation differently than WikipediaWe make sure the top-level topic (in this case, [[Snake]], is a redirect so that no one will be tempted to create a new article if there is a redlink to it.}}
== Disambiguation page ==


The {{tl|disambig}} template should be added to the top of all disambiguation pagesThis will automatically add the page to the [[:Category:Disambiguation]]Please do not assign any other category or workgroup to a disambiguation page. The disambiguation template automatically expunges all other categories.  
A '''disambiguation page''' is a page, found by searching, that lists multiple articles containing the searched-for word, called the ''Keyword'' in this pageFor reasons of fairness, the policy in The Citizendium is that '''no article gets to occupy the ''Keyword'' space''', because that would make it dominant to all other articles containing "Keyword"'''Article ''Keyword'' should always redirect to ''Keyword (disambiguation)''''', a page which will list all of the articles pertaining to ''Keyword''.


In the page itself, please define each sense of the disambiguated term using the {{tl|rpl}} template, eg {{tl|rpl|Test}}. This template differs from the standard {{tl|r}} found in the [[CZ:Related Articles|Related Articles]] section of each article, providing a definition of the term plus a status bar of article development, and is used specifically for disambiguation pages.
The disambiguation page must be a plain page; it should not be assigned to any other category or workgroup, should not have a /Definition page, nor have subpages. The disambiguation page should always be named ''Keyword (disambiguation)''.


By using {{tl|rpl}}, writing a definition on the disambiguation page itself is not necessary. If a definition is missing, it can be added by clicking on the "[e]" (edit) at the end of each definition link, or added via the article's Talk subpage link.
An example of a disambiguation page is [[Paris (disambiguation)]]. If you go directly to [[Paris]], you should be redirected immediately to [[Paris (disambiguation)]].


See also [[CZ:Naming Conventions|naming conventions]], [[CZ:Proposals/Disambiguation mechanics|disambiguation mechanics]] and [[CZ:List of words with multiple uses|list of multi-use words]].
There are two things that should appear in a disambiguation page:
# <big><nowiki>{{disambig}}</nowiki></big> must be included in the top of a disambiguation page; this adds the page to the [[:Category:Disambiguation]]
# List the articles about ''Keyword'' using the <big><nowiki>{{rpl|Article name}}</nowiki></big><ref><big><nowiki>{{rpl|Article name}}</nowiki></big> differs from <big><nowiki>{{r|Article name}}</nowiki></big>; the latter is used on <big>[[CZ:Related Articles|Related Articles]]</big> subpages</ref> format, with the most likely to be wanted near the top.


=== Disambiguation pages ===
Each article so listed will display as a bullet item with the <big><nowiki>[[Article name/Definition]]</nowiki></big> page contents shown to the right, plus an icon showing the article's development status.
The function of a disambiguation page is ''strictly'' to list the various articles (including planned articles) that go under a title.  [[Linux (disambiguation)]] is a good example.  Typically, disambiguation pages are marked with "disambiguation" parentheses, but not always; again, [[FERA]] is an example.


Please ''do not'' list senses of a word for which there are no articles planned; a disambiguation page is merely a device to redirect people, not to enlighten them about all the different ways that a word or phrase is usedIt is also unnecessary to list related articles; for example, it is not necessary to list Linux creator [[Linus Torvalds]] on the [[Linux (disambiguation)]] page, since Torvalds is not a sense of "Linux." Presumably, people will arrive at the disambiguation page looking specifically for a pointer to an article that goes under the title in question; anything else including references and footnotes, is an unnecessary distraction.
NOTE: There are a couple of ways to create a DefinitionOne is by looking at the Disambiguation page and clicking on the "[e]" (edit) at the end of each definition linkAnother is from the Discussion page of the disambiguated article, by clicking the appropriate link near the top of the Discussion subpage.


If you have a deep burning urge to list everything you can think of that is related to a topic, you ''don't'' want to make a disambiguation page.  You want to make a [[CZ:Related Articles|Related Articles]] page (which see).
== Disambiguated articles ==


In each disambiguated article (listed in the disambiguation page), two things are needed:
# <big><nowiki>{{dambigbox|Article name|Keyword}}</nowiki></big> should be placed at the top of each disambiguated article to help readers find other meanings of the searched-on keyword
# A definition should be created, if it doesn't already exist, at <big><nowiki>[[Article name/Definition]]</nowiki></big>; the contents of the definition page will appear on the disambiguation page if the article is listed as described above.  Definitions should be as short as possible.


{{Content Policy}}
An example of a disambiguated article is [[Paris, Tennessee]].  It's definition is at [[Paris, Tennessee/Definition]].
 
== See also ==
 
* [[CZ:Naming Conventions]]
* [[CZ:List of words with multiple uses]] - this is a housekeeping list
 
== Notes ==

Latest revision as of 11:39, 9 March 2024

Citizendium Content Policy
Approval Standards | Article Mechanics | Subpages | Importing material from other sources | Citable articles

|width=10% align=center style="background:#F5F5F5"|  |}

The Snake redirect needs to be restored, as Citizendium handles disambiguation differently than Wikipedia. We make sure the top-level topic (in this case, Snake, is a redirect so that no one will be tempted to create a new article if there is a redlink to it.

Disambiguation page

A disambiguation page is a page, found by searching, that lists multiple articles containing the searched-for word, called the Keyword in this page. For reasons of fairness, the policy in The Citizendium is that no article gets to occupy the Keyword space, because that would make it dominant to all other articles containing "Keyword". Article Keyword should always redirect to Keyword (disambiguation), a page which will list all of the articles pertaining to Keyword.

The disambiguation page must be a plain page; it should not be assigned to any other category or workgroup, should not have a /Definition page, nor have subpages. The disambiguation page should always be named Keyword (disambiguation).

An example of a disambiguation page is Paris (disambiguation). If you go directly to Paris, you should be redirected immediately to Paris (disambiguation).

There are two things that should appear in a disambiguation page:

  1. {{disambig}} must be included in the top of a disambiguation page; this adds the page to the Category:Disambiguation.
  2. List the articles about Keyword using the {{rpl|Article name}}[1] format, with the most likely to be wanted near the top.

Each article so listed will display as a bullet item with the [[Article name/Definition]] page contents shown to the right, plus an icon showing the article's development status.

NOTE: There are a couple of ways to create a Definition. One is by looking at the Disambiguation page and clicking on the "[e]" (edit) at the end of each definition link. Another is from the Discussion page of the disambiguated article, by clicking the appropriate link near the top of the Discussion subpage.

Disambiguated articles

In each disambiguated article (listed in the disambiguation page), two things are needed:

  1. {{dambigbox|Article name|Keyword}} should be placed at the top of each disambiguated article to help readers find other meanings of the searched-on keyword
  2. A definition should be created, if it doesn't already exist, at [[Article name/Definition]]; the contents of the definition page will appear on the disambiguation page if the article is listed as described above. Definitions should be as short as possible.

An example of a disambiguated article is Paris, Tennessee. It's definition is at Paris, Tennessee/Definition.

See also

Notes

  1. {{rpl|Article name}} differs from {{r|Article name}}; the latter is used on Related Articles subpages