Linux naming controversy: Difference between revisions

From Citizendium
Jump to navigation Jump to search
imported>Eric M Gearhart
(Fixed merge stuff. OK Josh you're working on it I see)
imported>Eric M Gearhart
(Wording and flow)
Line 1: Line 1:
In 1983, [[The Free Software Foundation]], founded by [[Richard Stallman|Dr. Richard Stallman]], made an attempt to create a [[free software movement|free]] [[Unix]]-like operating system, which they called the [[GNU system]] as a [[recursive acronym]] for '''''G'''NU's '''N'''ot '''U'''nix''.<ref>{{cite web
In 1983, [[The Free Software Foundation]], founded by [[Richard Stallman|Dr. Richard Stallman]], set out on an attempt to create a [[free software movement|free]] [[Unix]]-like operating system, which they called the [[GNU system]] as a [[recursive acronym]] for '''''G'''NU's '''N'''ot '''U'''nix''.<ref>{{cite web
| name=GNU
| name=GNU
| url=http://gnu.org
| url=http://gnu.org
| title=About the GNU Project
| title=About the GNU Project
| date=Retreived 06 April 2007
| date=Retreived 06 April 2007
}}</ref> They began with the necessary tools for the system, such as a [[GNU C compiler|compiler]], a [[debugger]], and a [[Emacs|text editor]]. Their plan was to then create a kernel to place beneath the tools that they had created.   
}}</ref> They began with the necessary tools for the system, such as a [[GNU C compiler|compiler]], a [[C library]] (glibc), a [[debugger]] (gdb), and a [[text editor]] (emacs). Their plan was to create all the tools necessary for an operating system, culminating with a kernel (the [[HURD]]) to place beneath the tools that they had created.   


The [[HURD]] team chose to base their architecture on a [[Mach microkernel]] design, which, from an academic standpoint seemed to be the next evolutionary step in [[kernel]] architecture.
The team of developers of this kernel chose to base their architecture on a [[Mach microkernel]] design, which, from an academic standpoint seemed to be the next evolutionary step in [[kernel]] architecture. In hindsight this ambition would cause GNU to lose their monopoly on the burgeoning free Unix scene.


However, due to the very complex structure of this new type of kernel, it took them an extremely long time compared to [[Monolithic kernel|Monolithic kernels]] to get a workable release. To this day, development of the [[HURD]] (the GNU kernel) continues without a stable first release.
Due to the complex structure of this new type of kernel, it took developers an extremely long time  
to get a workable release, compared to [[Monolithic kernel|Monolithic kernels]] that "just worked." As of April 2007, development of the [[HURD]] kernel continues without a stable first release.


It was during this time that Torvalds first introduced his kernel, which came to be called [[Linux]]. Before Linux, [[hacker|hackers]] had no choice but to use non-free kernels, most notably [[Minix]]. While the GNU kernel began to look more like [[vaporware]] every day, the community received Linux with open arms and many began to contribute.
In 1991 [[Linus Torvalds]] first introduced his kernel, which came to be called [[Linux]]. Before Linux, [[hacker|hackers]] had no choice but to use non-free kernels, most notably [[Minix]], atop the free GNU utilities and tools. While the GNU kernel began to look more like [[vaporware]] every day, the community received Linux with open arms and many began to contribute.


From gnu.org: "Variants of the GNU operating system, which use the kernel called Linux, are now widely used; though these systems are often referred to as “Linux”, they are more accurately called GNU/Linux systems."
From gnu.org: "Variants of the GNU operating system, which use the kernel called Linux, are now widely used; though these systems are often referred to as “Linux”, they are more accurately called GNU/Linux systems."

Revision as of 16:34, 11 April 2007

In 1983, The Free Software Foundation, founded by Dr. Richard Stallman, set out on an attempt to create a free Unix-like operating system, which they called the GNU system as a recursive acronym for GNU's Not Unix.[1] They began with the necessary tools for the system, such as a compiler, a C library (glibc), a debugger (gdb), and a text editor (emacs). Their plan was to create all the tools necessary for an operating system, culminating with a kernel (the HURD) to place beneath the tools that they had created.

The team of developers of this kernel chose to base their architecture on a Mach microkernel design, which, from an academic standpoint seemed to be the next evolutionary step in kernel architecture. In hindsight this ambition would cause GNU to lose their monopoly on the burgeoning free Unix scene.

Due to the complex structure of this new type of kernel, it took developers an extremely long time to get a workable release, compared to Monolithic kernels that "just worked." As of April 2007, development of the HURD kernel continues without a stable first release.

In 1991 Linus Torvalds first introduced his kernel, which came to be called Linux. Before Linux, hackers had no choice but to use non-free kernels, most notably Minix, atop the free GNU utilities and tools. While the GNU kernel began to look more like vaporware every day, the community received Linux with open arms and many began to contribute.

From gnu.org: "Variants of the GNU operating system, which use the kernel called Linux, are now widely used; though these systems are often referred to as “Linux”, they are more accurately called GNU/Linux systems."

The GNU Project members decided to call 'Linux' GNU/Linux, in order to attribute credit to those who worked hard at creating the tools that the Linux kernel runs. Linus Torvalds, however, has made no effort to hide his thoughts towards this naming convention, saying that "calling Linux in general just 'GNU/Linux' I think is ridiculous."[2]

References

  1. About the GNU Project (Retreived 06 April 2007).
  2. The "GNU/Linux" and "Linux" Controversy (Retreived 06 April 2007).

Related topics