Bach flower therapy: Difference between revisions

From Citizendium
Jump to navigation Jump to search
imported>Howard C. Berkowitz
No edit summary
imported>Gareth Leng
No edit summary
Line 12: Line 12:
  | publisher = Bach Centre}}</ref> The 38 specific plants, and the emotional states for which they are indicated, are listed on the [[Bach flower therapy/Catalogs|Catalogs subpage]].
  | publisher = Bach Centre}}</ref> The 38 specific plants, and the emotional states for which they are indicated, are listed on the [[Bach flower therapy/Catalogs|Catalogs subpage]].


It has not gained any acceptance in conventional medicine or mainstream science. A literature review  in 2009 concluded that "Bach flower remedies (BFR)" are probably safe. Few controlled prospective trials of BFRs for psychological problems and pain exist. Our analysis of the four controlled trials of BFRs for examination anxiety and ADHD indicates that there is no evidence of benefit compared with a placebo intervention."<ref>{{citation
There is no rational or scientific basis for believing that Bach flower therapy would have any effects beyond those that are induced by suggestion - i.e. [[placebo]] effects, and it is not something that has been considered worthy of any serious scientific attention. There have been a few assessments of its effects on patients, and it is thought to probably be safe.<ref>{{citation
  | title = Bach Flower Remedies for psychological problems and pain: a systematic review
  | title = Bach Flower Remedies for psychological problems and pain: a systematic review
  | author = Kylie Thaler, Angela Kaminskil, Andrea Chapman, Tessa Langley and Gerald Gartlehner
  | author = Thaler K ''et al.''
  | journal = BMC Complementary and Alternative Medicine | year = 2009 | volume =  9 |  page = 16 | doi=10.1186/1472-6882-9-16
  | journal = BMC Complementary and Alternative Medicine | year = 2009 | volume =  9 |  page = 16 | doi=10.1186/1472-6882-9-16
  | url = http://www.biomedcentral.com/1472-6882/9/16
  | url = http://www.biomedcentral.com/1472-6882/9/16
}}</ref> Another study, however, found "A double-blind clinical trial comparing a standard dosage of BFE Rescue Remedy against a placebo of identical appearance was conducted in a sample of 111 individuals aged 18 to 49, randomized into treatment (n = 53) and control (n = 58) groups...only the high-state anxiety treatment subgroup demonstrated a statistically significant difference between pretest and posttest scores. The results suggest that BFE Rescue Remedy may be effective in reducing high levels of situational anxiety."<ref name=Halberstein>{{citation
}}</ref> Like other healing rituals that work through the power of suggestion, it may have some benefits in relieving anxiety, with some consequential health benefits. <ref name=Halberstein>{{citation
  | title = (Abstract) Healing With Bach® Flower Essences: Testing a Complementary Therapy
  | title = (Abstract) Healing With Bach® Flower Essences: Testing a Complementary Therapy
  | author =  Robert Halberstein,  Lydia DeSantis, Alicia Sirkin, Vivian Padron-Fajardo, Maria Ojeda-Vaz
  | author =  Halberstein R ''et al.'' | doi = 10.1177/1533210107300705 | journal = Complementary Health Practice Review | date = January 2007 | volume =12| pages = 3-14  
| doi = 10.1177/1533210107300705 | journal = Complementary Health Practice Review | date = January 2007 | volume =12| issue  1 | pages = 3-14  
  | url =http://chp.sagepub.com/content/12/1/3
  | url =http://chp.sagepub.com/content/12/1/3
}}}</ref>
}}}</ref>

Revision as of 05:15, 28 January 2011

This article is developing and not approved.
Main Article
Discussion
Related Articles  [?]
Bibliography  [?]
External Links  [?]
Citable Version  [?]
Catalogs [?]
 
This editable Main Article is under development and subject to a disclaimer.

Bach flower therapy is an unproven health treatment that, according to a U.K. Parliament study, asserts that flowers contain the life force of a plant and that this is then imprinted into water through "sun infusion", producing a plant extract that is diluted before administration. This is then used to create remedies, which are usually ingested by the patient, and are purported to help them let go of "negative thoughts".[1] The practice was originated and developed by English homeopath Edward Bach (pronounced "Batch", 1886–1936).[2] The 38 specific plants, and the emotional states for which they are indicated, are listed on the Catalogs subpage.

There is no rational or scientific basis for believing that Bach flower therapy would have any effects beyond those that are induced by suggestion - i.e. placebo effects, and it is not something that has been considered worthy of any serious scientific attention. There have been a few assessments of its effects on patients, and it is thought to probably be safe.[3] Like other healing rituals that work through the power of suggestion, it may have some benefits in relieving anxiety, with some consequential health benefits. [4]

Bach therapy and phytotherapy

While Bach remedies are derived from plants, the principle is different than phytotherapy (i.e., herbalism). Herbalism assumes the existence of significant healing ingredient(s) in the plant extract.

Bach remedies, however, are more related to the "signatures" of Paracelsus; Bach indeed uses the term "signature". The remedies work on a mental level that transfers the "vibrations" or signature; the vibrations resonate with inherent vibrations believed to be in human cells. According to Bach practitioners, the remedies do not have detectable levels of active chemicals.[5] Independent microchemical analysis does not appear to be available.

Bach therapy and aromatherapy

While there may seem to be a similarity in that flowers contain essential oils, the preparation methods are quite different. Bach extracts use, in chemical terms, solvent extraction, while essential oils are usually extracted with steam distillation.

Bach therapy and homeopathy

Bach flower therapy and homeopathy have similarities in that they involve remedies intended to improve a vital force, and they both have a concept of potentizing. At that point, they diverge significantly. Preparation of the remedies, however, is different. Bach remedies are not selected using the homeopathic principle of the Laws of Similars.

The means of Bach remedy preparation uses a method, described in the British Homeopathic Pharmacopeia, that is used to prepare homeopathic mother tinctures. One involves extraction using ethanol, of a specific type of brandy and extracting with sunshine, while the other involves boiling the flowers with water. Once extracted, however, the tincture is used in a very different manner than in homeopathy.[6]

Bach potentizing

There is dilution, but to what homeopaths call a 5X dilution, which gives a much higher concentration than used in homeopathy.[7]

Efficacy testing

Tbere are a limited number of trials, with small samples; only abstracts were available for this article. They primarily dealt with anxiety. One double-blinded randomized controlled trial, comparing a Bach extract against placebo, reduced situational anxiety in a group of 111 patients.[4]

References

  1. Select Committee appointed to consider Science and Technology, U.K. Parliament (21 November 2000), Chapter 2: Disciplines examined, Definitions of the Various CAM Therapies, Complementary and Alternative Medicine
  2. Our founder, Dr Edward Bach, Bach Centre
  3. Thaler K et al. (2009), "Bach Flower Remedies for psychological problems and pain: a systematic review", BMC Complementary and Alternative Medicine 9: 16, DOI:10.1186/1472-6882-9-16
  4. 4.0 4.1 Halberstein R et al. (January 2007), "(Abstract) Healing With Bach® Flower Essences: Testing a Complementary Therapy", Complementary Health Practice Review 12: 3-14, DOI:10.1177/1533210107300705}
  5. The Principles of Bach Essence
  6. The Production of Bach Flower Essences
  7. The Theory of Bach Flower Therapy