Bach flower therapy: Difference between revisions

From Citizendium
Jump to navigation Jump to search
imported>Howard C. Berkowitz
No edit summary
imported>Howard C. Berkowitz
No edit summary
Line 17: Line 17:
While there may seem to be a similarity in that flowers contain essential oils, the preparation methods are quite different. Bach extracts use, in chemical terms, solvent extraction, while essential oils are usually extracted with steam [[distillation]]
While there may seem to be a similarity in that flowers contain essential oils, the preparation methods are quite different. Bach extracts use, in chemical terms, solvent extraction, while essential oils are usually extracted with steam [[distillation]]
==Bach therapy and homeopathy==
==Bach therapy and homeopathy==
Bach flower therapy and [[homeopathy]] have similarities in that they involve remedies intended to improve a ''vital force'', and they both have a concept of potentizing. At that point, they diverge significantly. Preparation of the remedies, however, is different. Bach remedies are not selected using the homeopathic principle of the Laws of Similars.  
Bach flower therapy and [[homeopathy]] have similarities in that they involve remedies intended to improve a [[vitalism|''vital force'']], and they both have a concept of potentizing. At that point, they diverge significantly. Preparation of the remedies, however, is different. Bach remedies are not selected using the homeopathic principle of the Laws of Similars.  


The  means of Bach remedy preparation uses a method, described in the ''British Homeopathic Pharmacopeia'', that is used to prepare homeopathic ''mother tinctures''. One involves extraction using [[ethanol]], of a specific type of [[brandy]] and extracting with sunshine, while the other involves boiling the flowers with water. Once extracted, however, the tincture is used in a very different manner than in homeopathy.  <ref name=BachPrep>{{citation
The  means of Bach remedy preparation uses a method, described in the ''British Homeopathic Pharmacopeia'', that is used to prepare homeopathic ''mother tinctures''. One involves extraction using [[ethanol]], of a specific type of [[brandy]] and extracting with sunshine, while the other involves boiling the flowers with water. Once extracted, however, the tincture is used in a very different manner than in homeopathy.  <ref name=BachPrep>{{citation

Revision as of 17:27, 23 January 2011

This article is developing and not approved.
Main Article
Discussion
Related Articles  [?]
Bibliography  [?]
External Links  [?]
Citable Version  [?]
Catalogs [?]
 
This editable Main Article is under development and subject to a disclaimer.

Bach flower therapy, according to a U.K. Parliament study, assumes that flowers contain the life force of the plant and this is imprinted into water through sun infusion which is used to make the flower remedy. Flower remedies are often used to help patients let go of "negative thoughts"; usually flower remedies are ingested.[1] It has not gained any significant acceptance in conventional medicine.

Bach therapy and phytotherapy

While Bach remedies are derived from plants, the principle is different than phytotherapy (i.e., herbalism). Herbalism assumes that there is a significant healing ingredient(s) in the plant extract.

Bach remedies, however, are more related to the "signatures" of Paracelsus; Bach indeed uses the term "signature". The remedies work on a mental level that tranfers the "vibrations" or signature; the vibrations resonate with inherent vibrations believed to be in human cells. The remedies do not have detectable levels of active chemicals. [2]

Bach therapy and aromatherapy

While there may seem to be a similarity in that flowers contain essential oils, the preparation methods are quite different. Bach extracts use, in chemical terms, solvent extraction, while essential oils are usually extracted with steam distillation

Bach therapy and homeopathy

Bach flower therapy and homeopathy have similarities in that they involve remedies intended to improve a vital force, and they both have a concept of potentizing. At that point, they diverge significantly. Preparation of the remedies, however, is different. Bach remedies are not selected using the homeopathic principle of the Laws of Similars.

The means of Bach remedy preparation uses a method, described in the British Homeopathic Pharmacopeia, that is used to prepare homeopathic mother tinctures. One involves extraction using ethanol, of a specific type of brandy and extracting with sunshine, while the other involves boiling the flowers with water. Once extracted, however, the tincture is used in a very different manner than in homeopathy. [3]

Bach potentizing

There is dilution, but to what homeopaths call a 5X dilution, which gives a much higher concentration than used in homeopathy. [4]

Efficacy testing

Tbere are a limited number of trials, with small samples; only abstracts were available for this article. They primarily dealt with anxiety. One double-blinded randomized controlled trial, comparing a Bach extract against placebo, reduced situational anxiety in a group of 111 patients. [5]

References

  1. Select Committee appointed to consider Science and Technology, U.K. Parliament (21 November 2000), Chapter 2: Disciplines examined, Definitions of the Various CAM Therapies, Complementary and Alternative Medicine
  2. The Principles of Bach Essence
  3. The Production of Bach Flower Essences
  4. The Theory of Bach Flower Therapy
  5. "Healing With Bach® Flower Essences: Testing a Complementary Therapy", Complementary Health Practice Review 12 (1): 3-14, 2007, DOI:10.1177/1533210107300705