Talk:Circulatory system: Difference between revisions
imported>Nancy Sculerati MD (Circulatory System: Starting the CZ Version) |
imported>Nancy Sculerati MD No edit summary |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
== Circulatory System: Starting the CZ Version == | == Circulatory System: Starting the CZ Version == | ||
Well, first of all, when I put in "Circulatory System" in the citizendium search box, I was promptly directed to a minor psychedelic band circa 2000 rather than the "organ system". That needs to be fixed as there will be many links to the organ system, but fewer to the band, and there has to be some kind of better directing sign than whether the "s" of System is capitalized. The way that the wikipedia article is laid out is not wrong, but it is not useful. It takes the stance that the article is about the whole gestalt of circulatory systems, that there are organisms that have systems that circluate substances and those that don't, and that these systems can therefore be open, closed, and non-existant. | Well, first of all, when I put in "Circulatory System" in the citizendium search box, I was promptly directed to a minor psychedelic band circa 2000 rather than the "organ system". That needs to be fixed as there will be many links to the organ system, but fewer to the band, and there has to be some kind of better directing sign than whether the "s" of System is capitalized. | ||
The way that the current "organ system" circulatory system wikipedia article is laid out is not wrong, but it is not useful. It is not actually about the organ system. It takes the stance that the article is about the whole gestalt of circulatory systems, that there are organisms that have systems that circluate substances and those that don't, and that these systems can therefore be open, closed, and non-existant. | |||
Although the circulation of substances within an organism (or corporation for that matter ;-) ) is an important concept, it is more important to have an article with the title "Circulatory System" that discusses the vertebrate circulatory system with the human system featured, as this ties in to so many articles on medical topics as well as biology. For example, a reader should be able to go from [[blood]] to [[bone marrow]] to [[heart]] to [[hypertension]] to [[circulatory system]] and keep things reasonably in context, without being suddenly confronted by music makers or jellyfish. On the other hand, the band and the invertebrate systems do deserve a place. [[User:Nancy Sculerati MD|Nancy Sculerati MD]] 14:21, 29 December 2006 (CST) | Although the circulation of substances within an organism (or corporation for that matter ;-) ) is an important concept, it is more important to have an article with the title "Circulatory System" that discusses the vertebrate circulatory system with the human system featured, as this ties in to so many articles on medical topics as well as biology. For example, a reader should be able to go from [[blood]] to [[bone marrow]] to [[heart]] to [[hypertension]] to [[circulatory system]] and keep things reasonably in context, without being suddenly confronted by music makers or jellyfish. On the other hand, the band and the invertebrate systems do deserve a place. [[User:Nancy Sculerati MD|Nancy Sculerati MD]] 14:21, 29 December 2006 (CST) | ||
Revision as of 15:23, 29 December 2006
Circulatory System: Starting the CZ Version
Well, first of all, when I put in "Circulatory System" in the citizendium search box, I was promptly directed to a minor psychedelic band circa 2000 rather than the "organ system". That needs to be fixed as there will be many links to the organ system, but fewer to the band, and there has to be some kind of better directing sign than whether the "s" of System is capitalized.
The way that the current "organ system" circulatory system wikipedia article is laid out is not wrong, but it is not useful. It is not actually about the organ system. It takes the stance that the article is about the whole gestalt of circulatory systems, that there are organisms that have systems that circluate substances and those that don't, and that these systems can therefore be open, closed, and non-existant.
Although the circulation of substances within an organism (or corporation for that matter ;-) ) is an important concept, it is more important to have an article with the title "Circulatory System" that discusses the vertebrate circulatory system with the human system featured, as this ties in to so many articles on medical topics as well as biology. For example, a reader should be able to go from blood to bone marrow to heart to hypertension to circulatory system and keep things reasonably in context, without being suddenly confronted by music makers or jellyfish. On the other hand, the band and the invertebrate systems do deserve a place. Nancy Sculerati MD 14:21, 29 December 2006 (CST)