Think tank

From Citizendium
Revision as of 17:58, 10 September 2009 by imported>Howard C. Berkowitz (New page: A '''think tank''' is an organization that presents ideas presented as expert analysis. Most think tank reports is presented as the product of specialists that are not pure consultants, fo...)
(diff) ← Older revision | Latest revision (diff) | Newer revision → (diff)
Jump to navigation Jump to search

A think tank is an organization that presents ideas presented as expert analysis. Most think tank reports is presented as the product of specialists that are not pure consultants, for which all work is billable, but who have time to research, study, and think.

Think tanks vary widely in the independence of their work. Many are little more than public relations fronts for a particular ideology or interest group, while others have a reputation for balance. Several reports put the Brookings Institution as among the most neutral and most frequently cited think tank. [1], and closest to the ideological center of similar organizations. [2] Other think tanks considered largely independent include the Center for Strategic and International Studies.

Many think tanks were created, by the U.S. government, at the end of the Second World War, for providing analysis either independent of government bias, or to use specialists who, for reasons ranging from salary to working conditions, did not want to work directly for government. The best known of these is the RAND Corporation, established by the United States Air Force. RAND and others, such as the MITRE Corporation and its MITREtek subsidiary, have diversified and are not solely dependent on government funding. Others, such as the Institute for Defense Analyses, restrict their contracts to government work, often highly classified.

In the private sector, a number of think tanks, such as the American Enterprise Institute or American Civil Liberties Union, have a stated ideological position, but may do substantive work within those assumptions. Groseclose and Milyo found that indicators of centrism were

  • the organization had closed membership (i.e., one could not simply join if sympathetic)
  • staff had titles such as fellow (including research fellow or senior fellow), researcher, economist, or analyst.

"Both variables seem to capture the conventional wisdom about which think tanks are known for quality scholarship. For instance, of the top-25 most-cited groups the following had both closed membership and staff called fellows", although several have a strong ideological position:

"Meanwhile, the following groups, which most would agree are more commonly known for activism than high-quality scholarship, had neither closed membership nor staff called fellows:"

Think tanks, not necessarily themselves strongly ideological, often provide a home for ideologically identified researchers, when their political party is out of power. As many George W. Bush Administration appointees came and went from AEI and the Hoover Institution, a number of Obama Administration officials came from the Center for a New American Security and the Belfer Center of Harvard University.

References

  1. Michael Dolny (March/April 2008), The Incredible Shrinking Think Tank: Third year in a row of declining citations
  2. Tim Groseclose and Jeffrey Milyo (November 2005), "A Measure of Media Bias", The Quarterly Journal of Economics