Talk:Alton Brown: Difference between revisions
imported>Mary Ash (→Response: modified response) |
imported>Mary Ash (→Response: typo) |
||
| Line 36: | Line 36: | ||
As this is a media story using IMDB as a '''starting''' point for a '''stub''' that '''you''' or any '''Citizen''' could expand is appropriate. Other '''sources''' you might want to check include Advertising Age. As this article is marked as a '''stub''' there is absolutely nothing wrong with how it's written or sourced. '''Stubs''' are meant to be expanded and are a '''WIP'''. '''David''' I am sure '''you''' realize this as you have vast '''experience''' with wikis. | As this is a media story using IMDB as a '''starting''' point for a '''stub''' that '''you''' or any '''Citizen''' could expand is appropriate. Other '''sources''' you might want to check include Advertising Age. As this article is marked as a '''stub''' there is absolutely nothing wrong with how it's written or sourced. '''Stubs''' are meant to be expanded and are a '''WIP'''. '''David''' I am sure '''you''' realize this as you have vast '''experience''' with wikis. | ||
Finally, David, you do not seem to realize this is a '''volunteer''' outfit and none of our paid to write here. We contribute what we can when we can. I am sorry '''you''' do not realize that this is a volunteer organization and you can not demand volunteers to do more than they wish. The article will be written and expanded when I have time unless some else, perhaps you, | Finally, David, you do not seem to realize this is a '''volunteer''' outfit and none of our paid to write here. We contribute what we can when we can. I am sorry '''you''' do not realize that this is a volunteer organization and you can not demand volunteers to do more than they wish. The article will be written and expanded when I have time unless some else, perhaps you, decide to add to it. | ||
As a reminder we are all '''volunteers''' who give what little time we have to make '''Citizendium''' a better place. [[User:Mary Ash|Mary Ash]] 08:45, 13 May 2011 (CDT) | As a reminder we are all '''volunteers''' who give what little time we have to make '''Citizendium''' a better place. [[User:Mary Ash|Mary Ash]] 08:45, 13 May 2011 (CDT) | ||
Revision as of 08:56, 13 May 2011
IMDB is a wiki for screen appearances. Most of their information is added by anonymous users, like on most wikis, and they do not claim that their information has any guarantee of accuracy. In fact their description page explains that that this system allows errors to creep in. IMDB should not be used as a reference. David Finn 01:24, 13 May 2011 (CDT)
By the way, I am not saying the information in this article is inaccurate or should be removed. I just mean that IMDB shouldn't be cited for the information. It could be replaced with a different citation or, since it is unquestionably true, even left without citation. David Finn 07:10, 13 May 2011 (CDT)
Response
David you seemed to ignore the local news coverage offered in the list of references:
Alton Brown ending Food Network’s ‘Good Eats’ after 249 episodes
3:55 pm May 12, 2011, by Rodney Ho CREDIT: AP
CREDIT: AP
Marietta food guru Alton Brown announced yesterday that after 249 episodes, he is shutting down “Good Eats,” a Food Network staple since 1999.
Beau Benton, his spokesman, confirmed that “Good Eats” will no longer be a regular series though Brown does plan three one-hour specials this year. He said Brown was not available for interviews.
Brown’s “Good Eats” has been a standard dish on Food Network’s menu for years, frequently in prime time. A fast-paced, intricately-created concoction, the show provides viewers with food history, cooking tips and oddball trivia on a single topic in Brown’s signature light-hearted and frequently sardonic tone. Over nearly 250 episodes, he chewed on almost every food subject there is, be it olives, steak or bouillabaisse. With some common staples like pasta or eggs, he’s done multiple episodes. And he’d hire local actors to play goofy parts.
One of those actors, Vickie Eng, who played the mysterious W character on about 30 episodes, said Brown put “blood, sweat and tears” into the show as director, writer and star. Her favorite moment was dangling from the ceiling Tom Cruise/”Mission Impossible” style for an episode on oysters.
Bobby Flay, another Food Network staple, said in an interview yesterday that he admires Brown for his “encyclopedic knowledge” of food and how he’s able to leverage that in multiple arenas.
Brown owns a 15,000-square-foot studio in Atlanta where he has shot “Good Eats.” Much of his staff and crew has been with him for years, a testament to his good works as a boss. “Everybody there is like family,” Eng said.
The Welch’s spokesman and author recently re-signed a new contract with Food Network and has an entrenched job with “Iron Chef” and its various incarnations. Undoubtedly, he has another show idea in his fridge.
The source is from an Atlanta newspaper and fed through the AP. This is a good source.
The IMDB offered a standard disclaimer. The IMDB started from Usenet, if I remember right, and is now owned by Amazon. As Amazon is a respected company, known for being a good Netzien, I suspect the information found within its database will be relatively accurate.
As this is a media story using IMDB as a starting point for a stub that you or any Citizen could expand is appropriate. Other sources you might want to check include Advertising Age. As this article is marked as a stub there is absolutely nothing wrong with how it's written or sourced. Stubs are meant to be expanded and are a WIP. David I am sure you realize this as you have vast experience with wikis.
Finally, David, you do not seem to realize this is a volunteer outfit and none of our paid to write here. We contribute what we can when we can. I am sorry you do not realize that this is a volunteer organization and you can not demand volunteers to do more than they wish. The article will be written and expanded when I have time unless some else, perhaps you, decide to add to it. As a reminder we are all volunteers who give what little time we have to make Citizendium a better place. Mary Ash 08:45, 13 May 2011 (CDT)